gold investment, silver investment

The Oil Stock Index and Its Relationship with the Stock Market

November 14, 2013, 8:57 AM

Based on the November 12th, 2013 Oil Investment Update

In our previous commentary, we took a look at the situation in crude oil from the long- and the short-term perspectives to check whether they confirm the indications from the medium-term picture or not. As we wrote in the summary:

(…) light crude reached the declining long-term support line, which may trigger a bigger pullback. Additionally, it bounced off the lower border of the declining trend channel in terms of daily closing prices, which may result in further growth in the coming days (similarly to what we saw in the previous month).

Since that essay was published, crude oil has remained in the narrow range, but yesterday it climbed above $95. What’s interesting, at the same time the XOI increased slightly above an important resistance. Although they moved in the same direction after weeks of negative correlation, this positive correlation might be just another temporary phenomenon – especially when we factor in the weekly outlook.

Taking the above into account, we’ve decided to examine another interesting relationship to see if there's something else on the horizon that could drive oil stocks higher or lower in the near future. It seems there is. In today’s essay we’ll focus on the connection between oil stocks and the general stock market. Let’s start with the weekly chart (charts courtesy by http://stockcharts.com).

XOI - NYSE Arca Oil Index - weekly chart

Looking at the above chart, we clearly see that the XOI and the S&P 500 have moved roughly in the same direction in the recent years. However, there were periods of time when the S&P 500 Index was stronger than the oil stock index. Such price action was clearly visible in September 2012. Back then, stocks managed to break above the previous 2012 top, but oil stocks only erased 90% of earlier losses. This divergence triggered a decline in both indices, but after the correction they continued their rally in the following weeks. We saw another similar situation in July 2013. Nevertheless, in spite of these cases, we can conclude that there is a strong positive correlation between the XOI and the S&P 500 Index.

Taking this fact into account, let’s examine the short-term picture.

XOI - NYSE Arca Oil Index - daily chart

On the above chart, we see that a strong positive correlation remains in place also on a short-term basis. After October’s rally, we saw a correction which pushed both indices slightly below the bottom of the previous corrective move. However, in case of the S&P 500, Friday’s pullback was visibly stronger. Although yesterday we saw further improvement in both indices, the XOI remains weaker in relation to the S&P500 index. Is it possible that this negative divergence between them will trigger another corrective move in both indices – similarly to what we’ve seen in the past on the weekly chart?

Taking into account the relationship described above, it seems important to discuss the current situation in the general stock market. The weekly chart of the S&P 500 index was featured in our latest Premium Update and you will find it below, along with a quote from today’s Market Alert:

Long-term S&P 500 Index chart - General Stock Market - SPX

The general stock market moved higher - above the previous highs but the breakout formed on low volume in both key stock market ETFs: DIA and SPY. Consequently, we remain skeptical about the strength of the stock market, especially that the True Seasonal patterns suggest a short-term decline any day now.

If stocks invalidate their breakout (which seems quite likely), we will have a very bearish sign for the short term – something that could easily ignite a 2-week pullback (rough estimate).

If stocks decline and the XOI-stocks link remains in place, then we can expect oil mining stocks to slide as well.

Summing up, since the general stock market is quite likely to invalidate its breakout and the oil-stocks-oil link is quite strong, we might see some weakness in oil stocks in the following days or weeks.

Please note that at this time we still have a promotional offer that allows you to subscribe to my Oil Investment Updates and Oil Trading Alerts for only $1 and $2, respectively, for the first 3 weeks of service. I encourage you to subscribe today.

Thank you.

Nadia Simmons
Sunshine Profits' Crude Oil Expert
Oil Investment Updates
Oil Trading Alerts

Did you enjoy the article? Share it with the others!

Apr Market Overview

Gold Market Overview

There has never been such a crisis. In matter of days, economies all over the world froze up. The stock markets plunged and the Wall Street experienced its largest single-day percentage drop since Black Monday in 1987. In response, the central banks shoots monetary bazookas while the governments are announcing mammoth stimulus packages.

If you feel lost, if you do not know what to think about the epidemic and its impact on the global economy and the gold market, or if you feel that the world has gone mad, you should definitely read this edition of the Market Overview.

As always, we focus on the gold market, so we analyze thoroughly how the epidemic, global recession and the resulting monetary policy and fiscal policy response will affect the price of the yellow metal.

Read more in the latest Market Overview report.

menu subelement hover background